🌵 Desert Mirage: Fletcher's False Promise of Tucson's Urban Renewal?

💼 Raytheon's Shadow: The Military-Industrial Complex Moves In 🎨 Cultural Preservation or Tokenism? The Sosa-Carrillo House Debate 👵 Abuelas to Yuppies: The Demographic Shift in Downtown Tucson

Based on the 8/27/24 Jump In Tucson Show on KVOI-1030AM in Tucson, AZ.

---

---

😽 Keepin’ It Simple Summary for Younger Readers
👧🏾✊🏾👦🏾

🏙️🌵 Tucson's downtown is changing fast! 🏗️ New buildings are going up, but old houses are being knocked down. 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 Some families who've lived there for a long time are having to move because it's getting too expensive. 🎨 The city says they're trying to make things better, but many people worry that the neighborhood is losing what made it special. 🏠 They're keeping a few old buildings to remember the past, but is that enough? 🤔 It's a big puzzle trying to make the city grow while also keeping its history and helping everyone who lives there. 🌈 People are working hard to find a solution that makes everyone happy!

---

---

🗝️ Takeaways

• 🏚️ Entire blocks of historic adobe homes in Barrio Viejo have been demolished for new developments

• 💰 Gentrification is pushing long-time, lower-income residents out of their neighborhoods

• 🎭 There's concern that cultural preservation efforts are more tokenism than genuine protection

• 🏭 The city's partnership with Raytheon raises ethical concerns about militarization

• 🌱 Environmental sustainability in new developments remains a significant concern

• 👥 Community input in urban planning decisions has been limited

• 💼 The focus on attracting high-income residents and businesses may be at odds with preserving community diversity

📚 Topics Discussed

🏙️ The Renaissance of Downtown Tucson

Fletcher McCusker's decision to move Providence Services downtown in 2010 marked the beginning of a significant transformation for Tucson's urban core. Downtown was largely abandoned then, with boarded-up buildings and little foot traffic. McCusker's investment in a neglected property block signaled a turning point. This move was soon followed by other major investments, including Tucson Electric Power's decision to build its headquarters nearby.

From a reader: The CEO of TEP who advocated to build downtown was Jim Pignatelli.

The introduction of the streetcar project further catalyzed development along its route, attracting businesses and residents alike.

🎵 Tucson's Emergence as a Music Destination

One of the most surprising outcomes of downtown Tucson's revitalization has been its rise as a prominent music city. Now ranked seventh in the United States for its music scene, Tucson has seen the development of world-class venues like the Century Room at Hotel Congress, which has become one of the top jazz clubs in the country. The Tucson Jazz Festival now attracts 25,000 visitors annually, with 65% coming from out of town. This focus on music has enriched the city's cultural fabric and driven economic growth through tourism and entertainment spending.

💰 The Economic Impact of Rio Nuevo

Under McCusker's leadership, the Rio Nuevo district has demonstrated the power of public-private partnerships in urban development. By leveraging tax increment financing, Rio Nuevo has achieved a remarkable 10-to-1 ratio of private to public investment, resulting in over $1 billion of private money flowing into downtown Tucson. This approach has revitalized the urban core and doubled the district's tax base, with projections for it to double again. The success of this model has attracted bipartisan support and led to the extension of Rio Nuevo's mandate until 2035.

🏘️ The Changing Face of Urban Living in Tucson

Contrary to initial expectations, downtown Tucson has attracted diverse residents. While the vibrant music and food scene was expected to draw millennials, a surprising 50% of downtown apartment dwellers are baby boomers. This demographic mix has contributed to a more robust and sustainable urban community. The appeal of walkable neighborhoods, cultural amenities, and a vibrant atmosphere has proven attractive to younger professionals and older adults looking to downsize and enjoy an active urban lifestyle.

💼 Downtown's Role in Economic Development

The revitalization of downtown Tucson has had far-reaching effects on the region's economic development. Major employers like Raytheon have reported that the vibrant downtown helps them recruit top talent. Site selectors, who previously saw little interest in Tucson's urban core, now view the downtown as a major asset for companies considering relocation. This transformation demonstrates how targeted urban renewal can broadly impact a region's economic competitiveness and ability to attract and retain skilled workers.

🎭 Balancing Growth and Culture

As Rio Nuevo continues its work, there's an increasing focus on balancing economic growth with cultural investments. Projects like the restoration of the Sosa Carrillo house and funding for public art and murals demonstrate a commitment to preserving and celebrating Tucson's diverse heritage (after being the ones that destroyed it). This approach aims to ensure that the benefits of urban renewal are shared broadly and that the city's unique character is maintained amidst rapid development.

🚗 Challenges and Future Directions

Despite its successes, downtown Tucson still faces challenges. The lack of retail options and parking difficulties remain obstacles to further growth. However, plans for developing the Ronstadt terminal and continued investment in cultural amenities suggest a bright future. As Rio Nuevo looks towards 2035 and beyond, the focus remains on creating a livable, walkable urban environment that can compete with other major cities in attracting residents, businesses, and visitors.

---

🌵 Three Sonorans Commentary

🌵 The Two Faces of Tucson's Renaissance: Gentrification, Cultural Erasure, and the Fight for Barrio Preservation

In the heart of the Sonoran Desert, a transformation has been underway. Once a vibrant and diverse community, Tucson's downtown has been reshaped by urban renewal projects that claim progress but often come at the cost of displacing entire neighborhoods and erasing cultural heritage.

Fletcher McCusker, the self-proclaimed architect of this revival, paints a rosy picture of Tucson's rebirth. "We've doubled the tax base," he boasts as if increased property values were the sole measure of a city's worth. But we must ask ourselves: at what cost has this "progress" come?

🏘️ The Gentrification Dilemma and Cultural Erasure

McCusker's vision of downtown Tucson conveniently glosses over the rich history and vibrant community that existed long before his "revitalization" efforts. The truth is that Tucson's downtown was already a thriving, diverse ecosystem, particularly in areas like Barrio Viejo. These historic neighborhoods were home to generations of Mexican-American families, small businesses, and a unique cultural tapestry that gave Tucson its soul.

Yet, in the name of progress, we've seen entire blocks of adobe homes - the very structures built by Tucson's original settlers - leveled to make way for new developments. The city celebrates preserving one token structure, the Sosa-Carrillo-Fremont House while bulldozing countless others that hold the memories and heritage of our community.

Pedro Gonzales, president of the Barrio Viejo Neighborhood Association, poignantly states, "The barrio will never disappear. It has gone through a lot of changes, even urban renewal, but it's the families that made the barrio no matter how many times the city [tried to move them]. They can't get rid of us."

This resilience is admirable, but it shouldn't have to come at such a high cost. The displacement of long-time residents, the erasure of cultural landmarks, and the homogenization of our urban landscape are steep prices to pay for what some call "progress."

🎭 Commodification of Culture

While McCusker pays lip service to cultural preservation, his words betray a cynical approach to our heritage. "We've got to pay attention to some of the cultural things so that we can attract, you know, the democratic vote," he says, reducing our rich traditions to mere political calculation.

Yes, the restoration of the Sosa-Carrillo house and funding for murals are steps in the right direction. But we must remain vigilant to ensure these efforts don't devolve into cultural tokenism, a façade to make gentrification more palatable. One preserved house cannot make up for the loss of entire communities.

🏭 The Specter of Militarization

Perhaps most troubling is McCusker's pride in how downtown development aids in recruiting for Raytheon. "Raytheon will tell you our downtown helps them recruit engineers," he boasts. But at what moral cost?

As progressives, we must question the wisdom of tying our city's economic future to the military-industrial complex. Raytheon's presence in our community not only raises ethical concerns but also makes us complicit in the global arms trade and the perpetuation of conflict.

🌍 Environmental Concerns

While the interview touches on the benefits of urban density and public transit like the streetcar, it fails to address the broader environmental implications of this rapid development. Are these new buildings energy-efficient? How are we managing water resources in our desert environment as we add more residents and businesses?

The push for a "vibrant downtown" must not come at the expense of sustainable practices and respect for our fragile Sonoran ecosystem.

🌈 The Path Forward: A Call to Action

As members of the Tucson community, we cannot stand idly by as our city is reshaped in the interests of the wealthy few, erasing the essence of what made Tucson unique. We must demand:

1. Preservation of existing historic structures and neighborhoods, not just token buildings

2. Affordable housing mandates in all new downtown developments

3. Celebration and protection of Chicano culture beyond superficial gestures

4. Support for local, minority-owned businesses over corporate chains

5. Ethical economic development that doesn't rely on the military-industrial complex

6. Stringent environmental standards for all new construction

7. Genuine community input in the planning process, not just lip service to "public-private partnerships"

The story of Tucson's revival is still being written. It's up to us, la gente, to seize the pen and ensure the next chapter is one of true inclusivity, sustainability, and cultural preservation. We must fight to keep the spirit of Barrio Viejo alive, not just in isolated preserved buildings but in our community's living, breathing fabric.

Our desert home deserves nothing less than a future that honors its past, respects its environment, and provides opportunity for all its children. ¡Adelante, Tucson! The struggle continues, but together, we can shape a city that reflects our values, dreams, and diverse heritage.

---

👩🏼‍🤝‍👨🏾 People Mentioned

Fletcher McCusker:

• CEO of UA Venture Capital

• Former CEO of Providence Services Corp

• Born in Tucson, left as a young adult, later returned

• Instrumental in the revitalization of downtown Tucson

• Appointed to the Rio Nuevo board in 2012

• Known for his involvement in music and community development

Steve Pierce:

• Former Arizona Senate President

• Appointed Fletcher McCusker to the Rio Nuevo board in 2012

Jim Click:

• Prominent Tucson businessman

• Influenced Steve Pierce to appoint McCusker to Rio Nuevo board

• Known for his automotive dealerships and community involvement

Kevin Madden:

• Owner of Madden Media

• Early investor in downtown Tucson, influencing McCusker's decision to invest

Richard Oseran:

• Owner of Hotel Congress

• Early investor in downtown Tucson

Paul Bonavia:

• Former CEO of Tucson Electric Power (TEP)

• Moved TEP headquarters downtown, following McCusker's investment

Patricia Schwabe:

• Landlord who owned the block McCusker purchased for Providence Services

George Kaiser:

• Former employee of Jim Click, involved in car repossession incident with McCusker

---

👁️ Propaganda AI-nalysis

Propaganda messages:

• Downtown revitalization is crucial for overall economic development

• Public-private partnerships are the most effective way to redevelop urban areas

• Music and culture are essential drivers of urban renewal

• Bipartisan support is necessary for long-term urban development projects

• Successful businesspeople make effective public servants

• Urban living appeals to both young professionals and retirees

Overt messages:

• Rio Nuevo has been successful in transforming downtown Tucson

• The streetcar project was a catalyst for downtown development

• Tucson's downtown is now a destination for dining and entertainment

• The tax base in the Rio Nuevo district has doubled

• Private investment has far outpaced public investment in downtown Tucson

Hidden messages:

• Government-led development projects can be inefficient without private-sector involvement

• Gentrification is a necessary part of urban renewal

• Cultural investments are necessary to attract high-paying jobs and talent

• Urban development should cater to those with disposable income

• The success of downtown development justifies continued public investment and tax incentives

Hidden opinions:

• Downtown development is more important than other areas of the city

• The benefits of urban renewal outweigh the potential negative impacts on existing communities

• Private sector leadership is superior to government management in development projects

• Cultural amenities should be prioritized over affordable housing or other social services

• The success of Rio Nuevo justifies its continued existence and funding

Claims made:

• Rio Nuevo has leveraged $10 of private investment for every $1 of public money

• The tax base in the Rio Nuevo district has doubled and is projected to double again

• Tucson is now the seventh-ranked music city in the United States

• 50% of downtown apartment dwellers are baby boomers

• Downtown revitalization helps major employers like Raytheon recruit talent

• Site selectors now view downtown Tucson as a major asset for relocation

• The Tucson Convention Center is fully booked, especially for music events

• Rio Nuevo owns cultural assets like the Sosa Carrillo house

• There are approximately 40 restaurants downtown, each generating $3 million in annual revenue

---

---

If you enjoyed this article, buy us a cup of coffee!

---

Previous Show:

---