🏛️ From Free College to $13K: How Arizona Betrayed Its Youth
🏛️ From Free College to $13K: How Arizona Betrayed Its Youth
🔍 The Hidden Cost of Economic Indicators 🎓 Education's Great Betrayal: From Public Good to Private Debt
Based on the 10/22/24 Buckmaster Show on KVOI-1030AM.
🧠 Mindmap of today’s show
🙊 Notable quotes from the show
"The youngest one that was unaccompanied was nine" - Kim Sisson, revealing the shocking reality of youth homelessness
"When I was growing up, I could go to college, four-year college, for free" - Shelly Fishman, contrasting past educational opportunities with current costs
"We've known for a while that the baby boomer generation was going to have the effect of aging on average, the American population. But what he's saying is, it's worse than that" - Shelly Fishman on demographic challenges
"If you can't trust the people that are closest to you it's hard to trust people that are looking for you to help" - Kim Sisson on challenges helping homeless youth
⏮️ ICYMI: From the Last Show…
😽 Keepin’ It Simple Summary for Younger Readers
👧🏾✊🏾👦🏾
📻 On today's radio show, grown-ups talked about two big problems in our city. First, they discussed how it's getting harder for people to afford college 📚 - it used to be free but now costs lots of money! Then, they talked about kids who don't have homes 🏠. A nice group called Stand Up for Kids helps these children by giving them food, clean clothes, and a safe place to go during the day. They even found a kid as young as 9 living on the streets! 😢 But there are people working hard to help make things better! 🌟
🗝️ Takeaways
🏭 Port workers' victory reveals broader labor crisis
👶 Discovery of 9-year-old homeless child exposes systemic failure
🎓 Higher education shifted from public good to private burden
🤖 Automation threatens jobs while corporations abandon training
🌍 Other nations better prepare workers for technological change
💔 278 new homeless youth in Tucson (2023) shows growing crisis
⏬ Jump to the 🦉 Three Sonorans Commentary based on:
📻 What They Discussed
On October 22, 2024, The Bill Buckmaster Show, broadcasting from Tucson's Green Thing Succoville Village studio, featured guest host Ben Buehler-Garcia filling in for Bill Buckmaster.
The show hosted two significant segments: first, financial advisor Shelly Fishman discussed economic trends and labor issues, followed by Kim Sisson, Executive Director of Stand Up for Kids Tucson Chapter, addressed youth homelessness.
💰 Economic Analysis & Labor Rights
Shelly Fishman analyzed current economic conditions, highlighting the complex dynamics of the recent port workers' strike and its resolution.
The discussion revealed the ongoing tension between labor and capital, with workers securing a 62% raise over five years despite initial resistance. Fishman noted that while this seems substantial, the impact on end-user costs would be minimal, raising questions about corporate profit margins and wage suppression.
The segment also addressed three major challenges Nobel Prize-winning economist Daron Acemoglu identified: aging population demographics, artificial intelligence's impact on employment, and global economic bifurcation.
🤖 Technology & Worker Displacement
Using McDonald's automation as an example, the conversation turned to automation and its impact on workers. Fishman highlighted a critical failure in American business culture: unlike other industrialized nations, U.S. corporations have largely abandoned worker training programs.
This shift coincided with the rise of 401(k)s replacing traditional pensions, fundamentally altering the employer-employee relationship and reducing corporate investment in workforce development.
🎓 Education Crisis
A particularly pointed discussion emerged around the privatization of higher education. Fishman noted how his generation could attend public universities for free, while today's students face substantial costs.
Using the University of Arizona as an example, where annual tuition is now $13,000, he argued this represents a deliberate policy shift from viewing education as a public good to treating it as an individual responsibility. This contrasts sharply with other industrialized nations maintaining free or low-cost higher education.
🏠 Youth Homelessness Crisis
The second segment with Kim Sisson revealed shocking statistics about youth homelessness in Tucson. Stand Up for Kids encountered 278 new homeless youth in 2023 alone, with nearly a thousand points of contact.
Most disturbingly, Sisson reported finding a nine-year-old child living unaccompanied on the streets. The organization provides essential services through street outreach and a new drop-in center, offering everything from basic necessities to educational support and job search assistance.
🤝 Community Response
The program detailed Stand Up for Kids' operational model, which runs entirely on volunteers and includes significant support from Davis-Monthan Air Force Base personnel.
The organization's approach emphasizes building trust through consistency, with the same volunteers returning to the same locations simultaneously.
This structure helps overcome the deep-seated trust issues many homeless youth have developed due to past trauma and abuse.
🌍 Global Economic Perspective
The show concluded with a broader discussion of global economic trends, noting America's relative economic strength (2.8% GDP growth) while highlighting structural issues.
The conversation discussed how other industrialized nations are better prepared for challenges like aging populations and technological displacement through more robust social support systems and worker protections.
🦉 Three Sonorans Commentary
"The Hidden Costs of American 'Prosperity'"
In a revealing episode of the Buckmaster Show, the stark contradictions of American capitalism were laid bare through two seemingly separate but deeply interconnected stories: labor struggles and youth homelessness in Tucson. As we peel back the layers, we see how these issues expose the fundamental failures of our economic system.
🏭 The Labor Struggle: More Than Just Numbers
While financial advisor Shelly Fishman celebrated America's 2.8% GDP growth as making us "the envy of the world," the real story lies in what's happening on the ground.
Port workers had to fight for a 62% raise over five years—a figure that sounds large until you realize it merely raises their wages to livable standards in coastal cities. The resistance to these raises exposes how corporate America consistently prioritizes profit over people.
📚 The Great Education Heist
Perhaps most telling was Fishman's inadvertent exposure of how the American Dream has been systematically dismantled.
His revelation that "When I was growing up, I could go to college, four-year college, for free" contrasted with today's $13,000 annual tuition at the University of Arizona tells the story of a deliberate policy shift that has transformed education from a public good into a private burden.
This shift disproportionately impacts communities of color and working-class families, continuing the cycle of economic segregation and opportunity hoarding.
👶 The Ultimate Cost: Our Children
The most heartbreaking revelation came from Kim Sisson of Stand Up for Kids, who reported finding a nine-year-old child living alone on Tucson's streets. This isn't just a tragedy - it's an indictment of our system. As Sisson noted, "If you can't trust the people that are closest to you, it's hard to trust people that are looking for you to help."
In 2023 alone, they encountered 278 new homeless youth in Tucson. Each of these cases represents a failure of our social safety net, our education system, and our economic policies.
🤖 Automation: The Next Wave of Displacement
The discussion of automation and AI revealed another looming crisis. While other industrialized nations prepare their workforces through training and education, American corporations have abandoned worker development.
As Fishman pointed out, this represents a dramatic shift from when corporations invested in their workers' futures.
💭 Critical Analysis
What's most striking about this episode is what wasn't discussed:
The role of systemic racism in youth homelessness
How immigration status affects access to services
The intersection of corporate tax breaks and underfunded social services
The environmental impact of port operations and corporate practices
🌟 Path Forward
This episode makes clear that real solutions require systemic change:
Return to treating education as a public good
Implement comprehensive worker protection and training programs
Create robust social safety nets
Address the root causes of youth homelessness
Challenge the narrative that GDP growth equals societal success
The stories shared on this show remind us that behind every economic indicator are real people, and behind every statistic is a child who deserves better than what our current system offers. As we move forward, we must ask ourselves: What kind of society allows nine-year-olds to live on the streets while celebrating stock market gains?
The answer lies not in more volunteer programs - though vital for immediate relief - but in fundamental systemic change prioritizing human dignity over corporate profits.
If you enjoyed this article, buy us a cup of coffee! We 🤎☕‼️
👯 People Mentioned
Bill Buckmaster - Regular host (absent this episode)
Referenced as being on vacation
Ben Buehler-Garcia - Guest host, host of American Warrior Radio
Notable for asking probing questions about economic inequality and youth homelessness
Shelly Fishman - Financial advisor
Key quote: "My generation has transferred the responsibility for training people post-secondary education from the taxpayer to the individual"
Provided critical analysis of economic shifts and education costs
Kim Sisson - Executive Director, Stand Up for Kids Tucson Chapter
Key quote: "The youngest one that was unaccompanied was nine"
"We met 278 [homeless youth] for the first time in 2023"
17+ years of experience working with homeless youth
Daron Acemoglu - Nobel Prize-winning MIT economist (referenced)
Identified three major economic challenges: aging population, AI impact, global economic bifurcation