💰 School Choice or Public School Sabotage? The ESA Debate Heats Up
📊 Alarming Statistics: Unpacking Tucson's Educational Achievement Gap 🔌 Green Fleet or Money Pit? Examining TUSD's Electric Bus Investment
Based on the 9/6/24 Wake Up Tucson Show on KVOI-1030AM in Tucson, AZ.
🧠🗺️ Mind Map of the Show 🗣️🎙️
😽 Keepin’ It Simple Summary for Younger Readers
👧🏾✊🏾👦🏾
📻 A radio show in Tucson talked about lots of things! 🏫 They said many kids in schools are having trouble reading. 💰 They argued about whether giving money to families for school is good or bad. 🚌 The school district bought some new electric buses, but some people think it was too expensive. 🎬 They talked about a famous old actor named Alec Guinness who was in Star Wars and other movies. 🌮 They also talked about yummy food at a local taco place. The people on the radio had strong opinions about all these things!
🗝️ Takeaways
📚 Reading proficiency rates in Tucson schools are alarmingly low, with only 30% of TUSD third graders reading at grade level
💵 Conservative think tanks argue that Empowerment Scholarship Accounts (ESAs) save taxpayer money, contrary to claims by Democratic officials
🚌 TUSD's purchase of electric school buses is criticized as wasteful spending by conservative commentators
🎭 The show featured an extensive discussion of actor Alec Guinness's career and films, highlighting classic Hollywood cinema
🌮 Local restaurant El Taco Rustico received positive coverage for its food offerings and expansion plans
📚 Topics Discussed
📚 Tucson's Literacy Crisis
The hosts discussed alarming statistics regarding reading proficiency in Tucson schools. They reported that only 30% of TUSD third graders and 42% of Amphi third graders can read at grade level. Overall, the reading proficiency rates for TUSD and Amphi were reported as 30% and 44% respectively. The hosts expressed concern about the long-term implications of these low literacy rates and criticized the effectiveness of public education.
The alarmingly low reading proficiency rates in Tucson schools – with only 30% of TUSD third graders reading at grade level – is indeed a crisis that demands our attention. However, the hosts' implicit suggestion that this is a failure of public education misses the mark entirely.
What they fail to acknowledge is the historical and ongoing underfunding of schools in predominantly Latinx and low-income neighborhoods. The literacy gap is not a reflection of student or teacher ability, but rather a stark illustration of educational inequality rooted in systemic racism and classism.
Moreover, the push for ESAs (Empowerment Scholarship Accounts) as a solution is a thinly veiled attempt to privatize education, which would further exacerbate these inequalities. Instead, we should be advocating for:
Increased funding for public schools, particularly in underserved areas
Bilingual and culturally responsive curricula that engage our diverse student population
Smaller class sizes to allow for more individualized attention
Comprehensive support services, including nutrition programs and mental health resources
By addressing the root causes of educational inequality, we can work towards a truly equitable education system that serves all of Tucson's children.
💰 The ESA Debate: Savings or Sabotage?
Most of the show discussed Empowerment Scholarship Accounts (ESAs) and their fiscal impact. Jason Bedrick from the Heritage Foundation argued that ESAs save taxpayer money, contrary to claims made by Democratic officials. The hosts criticized ProPublica and the Grand Canyon Institute analyses, suggesting bias in their reporting. This segment highlighted the ongoing debate over school choice and its economic implications.
🚌 TUSD's Electric Bus Controversy
The hosts scrutinized TUSD's recent purchase of 10 electric school buses for $6.2 million. They questioned the cost-effectiveness and practicality of this decision, comparing it unfavorably to the cost of traditional buses. The discussion touched on environmental sustainability and fiscal responsibility issues in public education.
🎭 Celebrating Alec Guinness: A Cinematic Legend
An extensive segment was dedicated to reviewing the career of actor Alec Guinness. The hosts discussed his top 10 films, including "Our Man in Havana," "The Lavender Hill Mob," and "Lawrence of Arabia." They praised Guinness's versatility as an actor and his impact on cinema, particularly noting his role in "Star Wars" and his professional influence on set.
🌮 El Taco Rustico: Tucson's Culinary Gem
The show featured a positive spotlight on the local restaurant El Taco Rustico. Owner Juan Almanza discussed the menu offerings at his two locations, highlighting items such as gorditas, smoked meats, and shrimp rojito. This segment provided a brief respite from political discussions and showcased local business.
🚓 Tucson's Crime Concerns
The hosts expressed worry about crime rates in Tucson, discussing a recent shooting incident and its impact on local businesses. They criticized the effectiveness of law enforcement response and highlighted concerns from local business owners about safety and economic stability in affected areas.
🎬 "Reagan": A Controversial Biopic
The show included a positive review of the film "Reagan," starring Dennis Quaid. The hosts noted the disparity between audience scores (98%) and critic reviews (21%) on Rotten Tomatoes, suggesting potential political bias in film criticism. This discussion touched on broader themes of media representation and political narratives in popular culture.
🗳️ Political Commentary and Upcoming Propositions
Throughout the show, the hosts offered conservative-leaning commentary on various political issues, including criticism of Democratic officials and policies. They discussed upcoming propositions and voting, encouraging listener engagement in local politics from a conservative perspective.
📰 Media Criticism and Cultural Commentary
The hosts expressed skepticism towards mainstream media and left-leaning outlets, particularly in their coverage of political issues and film reviews. They suggested that there is a systematic bias against conservative viewpoints in popular culture and media representation.
🌵 Three Sonorans Commentary
In a recent episode of Wake Up Tucson, a conservative radio show, hosts Chris DeSimone and Matt Neely once again demonstrated their penchant for pushing right-wing narratives that often misrepresent or oversimplify complex issues facing our community. As advocates for social justice, environmental protection, and equitable progress, we must deconstruct these arguments and offer a more nuanced, progressive perspective.
🏫 Education Equity: Beyond Test Scores and School Choice Propaganda
The hosts harped on low reading proficiency rates in Tucson schools, citing alarming statistics such as "Only 30 percent of the entire school district of TUSD can read at level." While literacy is undoubtedly a critical issue, their framing ignores the systemic inequalities and historical underfunding that have led to these outcomes.
Instead of advocating for increased resources, smaller class sizes, and culturally responsive curricula, the show promoted Empowerment Scholarship Accounts (ESAs) as a solution. Jason Bedrick from the Heritage Foundation claimed, "The Department of Education just released their budget for the year where they closed the fiscal year ending in June. And they had a $4.3 million surplus."
This myopic focus on budget surpluses and school choice obscures the real issues. ESAs and similar programs often exacerbate educational inequalities by diverting funds from public schools and benefiting more affluent families who can supplement the vouchers. As progressive Chicanos, we must push for equitable funding, support for multilingual education, and resources that address the specific needs of our diverse student population.
🌍 Environmental Justice: Electric Buses and Beyond
The hosts' criticism of TUSD's purchase of electric school buses reveals a shortsighted view of environmental policy. They mocked the initiative, saying, "They're paying $625… If I read the story right, they got a $4 million grant from the feds. They got a million from some sort of a rebate program from TEP. They got $1.2 million that you voted for."
This ridicule ignores the long-term environmental and health benefits of transitioning to clean energy, especially for communities of color who are disproportionately affected by air pollution. Instead of seeing this as wasteful spending, we should recognize it as an investment in our children's future and a step towards environmental justice.
Moreover, we should push for comprehensive climate action that addresses the unique challenges faced by desert communities like Tucson, including water conservation, sustainable urban planning, and protection of indigenous lands.
👮 Public Safety: Beyond Fearmongering and Over-policing
The show's discussion of crime in Tucson relied heavily on fear-based narratives, with quotes like "Businesses in the strip mall on the southwest corner of Speedway... Have relocated due to violence, leaving several vacant." This framing often leads to calls for increased policing, which historically results in the over-criminalization of Black and Brown communities.
As progressive advocates, we must shift the conversation towards addressing the root causes of crime: poverty, lack of mental health resources, and systemic racism. We should promote community-based solutions, restorative justice programs, and investments in social services that prevent crime before it occurs.
🎭 Cultural Representation: Beyond Hollywood Nostalgia
The show's lengthy discussion of Alec Guinness's career, while informative, highlighted the lack of diversity in classic Hollywood cinema. As we appreciate film history, we must also push for greater representation of BIPOC actors, directors, and stories in contemporary media.
The hosts' criticism of film reviews for movies like "Reagan" (Audience score 98%, Critic score 21%) reveals their bias towards conservative narratives. It's essential to recognize that critical analysis of political figures and their legacies is not inherently biased but necessary for a well-informed society.
Conclusion: Advancing a Progressive Vision for Tucson
The perspectives presented on Wake Up Tucson often reflect a narrow, conservative worldview that fails to address the complex challenges facing our diverse community. As progressive Chicanos, it's our responsibility to challenge these narratives and advocate for solutions that promote true equity, environmental justice, and social progress.
👩🏼🤝👨🏾 People Mentioned
Chris DeSimone (host): "This will be the next person to work in the Lane Santa Cruz office. It'll be fine."
Matt Neely (co-host): "Their customers prefer it. Right. It makes it inviting to their customers and employees."
Mark Van Buren (guest): "I love Alec Guinness. You know what? When I started doing these, first of all, I couldn't believe that I haven't done them yet, but he is, every one of these films that we're going to talk about is outstanding."
Juan Almanza: "It's like a masa tortilla packet. Cook it in the flat top and then to heat it, warm it up, we throw in the fryer for a couple minutes."
Jason Bedrick: "The Department of Education just released their budget for the year where they closed the fiscal year ending in June. And they had a $4.3 million surplus."
Katie Hobbs: "Katie Hobbs has been saying that it's bankrupting the state. It's unsustainable."
Alec Guinness: "He was the only person to receive a best acting nomination in any of the Star Wars movies."
Dennis Quaid: "I think Dennis Quaid did a good job. He had the voice down and you know how Reagan used to always say, well, you know, he had that down pretty well and I liked it."
Lois Pollack: "We hope the new businesses are good neighbors. Be a good neighbor. Being good neighbors not hard."
Raul Aguirre: Chris DeSimone, one of the hosts, criticizes the inclusion of Raul Aguirre in a news story about local business owners responding to Kamala Harris's tax relief plan. DeSimone suggests that Aguirre is not a neutral or representative source, saying: "You can't find a guy more connected to power and the machine in this place than this guy. It's like, it's like asking, he's like the version of like, it's asking Larry Hecker or one of the classic cronies of Pima County." The host implies that Aguirre is closely connected to the local political establishment and therefore not an impartial voice on the issue. The comment suggests that Aguirre's perspective would be biased in favor of the current political leadership or policies.
👁️ Propaganda AI-nalysis
Propaganda messages:
School choice and ESAs are beneficial for taxpayers and students
Public schools are failing to educate students effectively
Democratic leadership is mismanaging public funds and resources
Conservative policies are more fiscally responsible than progressive ones
Mainstream media and left-leaning think tanks are biased and unreliable
Overt messages:
Reading proficiency rates in Tucson schools are alarmingly low
ESAs save taxpayer money according to recent budget reports
TUSD's electric bus purchase is wasteful and impractical
Local law enforcement is ineffective in addressing crime
Conservative perspectives are underrepresented in mainstream media and film reviews
Hidden messages:
Public education is inherently flawed and should be replaced by private alternatives
Democratic policies are harmful to the economy and public safety
Progressive values are detrimental to society and should be rejected
Traditional cultural values, as represented in classic films, are superior to modern progressive ideals
Hidden opinions:
Public school teachers and administrators are incompetent or unmotivated
Democratic voters are uninformed or misguided
Progressive policies are driven by ideology rather than practicality
Conservative viewpoints are being unfairly silenced or marginalized in popular culture
Claims made:
Only 30% of TUSD third graders can read at grade level
ESAs result in a net savings for taxpayers
TUSD's electric bus purchase is more expensive than traditional buses
Crime rates in Tucson are causing businesses to relocate
Film critics are biased against conservative-themed movies
Alec Guinness was one of the greatest actors of all time
El Taco Rustico offers high-quality, authentic Mexican cuisine
If you enjoyed this article, buy us a cup of coffee!
Previous Show:
 | A guest post by
|