🚨 Pima County Supervisors Wrestle with Homelessness and Public Safety Amidst Calls for Action
🏠 Homelessness Crisis Takes Center Stage as Community Voices Concerns
😽 Keepin’ It Simple Summary for Younger Readers
👧🏾✊🏾👦🏾
The Pima County Board of Supervisors had a big meeting 🏛️ where they talked about helping people without homes 🏚️, keeping the community safe 🛡️, and giving money 💰 to important projects. Some people came to share their worries 😟 about homeless camps 🏕️ and crime 🚓. The Board also made decisions about selling alcohol 🍻 and appointing new people 👥 to help run things. They had some disagreements 🤔 but worked together 🤝 to make choices for the county 🏞️.
🗝️ Takeaways
🏘️ Homelessness remains a complex issue with no easy solutions, highlighting the need for comprehensive approaches beyond enforcement
💉 The "Stop Fentanyl at the Border Act" sparked debate on balancing enforcement with holistic solutions to drug issues
💻 IT security and data management in the Recorder's Office continue to raise concerns, particularly regarding outsourcing sensitive tasks
🤝 Collaboration between city and county entities is crucial for addressing regional issues like homelessness and public safety
💰 Federal funding and requirements for local programs continue to be a point of contention among board members
In a riveting meeting on September 3, 2024, the Pima County Board of Supervisors grappled with many pressing issues, chief among them the persistent challenges of homelessness and public safety. The session, marked by impassioned public comments and heated debates among supervisors, laid bare our community's deep-seated tensions and complexities.
🗣️ Voices from the Margins: Community Speaks Out
The call to the audience segment of the meeting brought forth a chorus of concerned citizens. Dr. Erinsen, a local veterinarian, shared a harrowing account of the impact of homeless encampments on his business and the surrounding area. His testimony underscored the urgent need for action, highlighting the delicate balance between compassion for the unhoused and preserving public safety and business interests.
Robert Royce offered a unique historical perspective, drawing from Thomas Jefferson's battle for religious freedom in 1779. He stated, "We shall now follow him through the most bitter fight he was ever to encounter. His fight for the complete separation of church and state." Royce's commentary served as a reminder of the foundational principles of religious freedom in America and their relevance to contemporary debates.
John Backer, an Air Force veteran and long-time Pima County resident, offered a critical analysis of the proposed "Stop Fentanyl at the Border Act," stating, "Now it goes without saying we know that that's a scourge to our civilization, our country, our state, our local communities that does need to be stopped. But the problem is if you haven't read the details of what that act entails I see little in there that is really going to even impact fentanyl. Nothing that's going to stop it."
An unnamed speaker raised concerns about election integrity, criticizing the Board for what they perceived as a lack of transparency and accountability in addressing chain of custody issues with ballots.
🏘️ Housing First or Law and Order: The Great Debate
Director Darland's presentation from the Office of Housing Opportunities and Homeless Solutions sparked a contentious discussion on the county's approach to homelessness. While Darland emphasized the importance of Housing First principles and the complexities of engaging individuals experiencing homelessness, Supervisor Christy pushed back, arguing for a stronger focus on law enforcement and addressing criminal activities associated with encampments.
"If this whole program... expressed a concern as equal or equivalent to providing public safety and protecting private property as much as it is for obtaining social services, this would have a lot more legitimacy in the eyes of the public," Supervisor Christy stated, highlighting the tension between social services and public safety approaches.
This debate reflects a broader national conversation on how to address homelessness effectively. While Housing First approaches have shown promise in many communities, the persistent concerns about public safety and quality of life continue to challenge policymakers and community leaders alike.
💉 The Border Battle: Fentanyl in the Crosshairs
The Board's consideration of Resolution 2024-53 in support of the "Stop Fentanyl at the Border Act" brought the national immigration and drug policy debate to the local level. The discussion revealed deep divisions not only on the board but within the community at large.
🖥️ Digital Dilemmas: Data Security and Outsourcing Concerns
The renewal of a contract with Thelios LLC for database management in the Recorder's Office sparked a heated debate about data security and the outsourcing of sensitive government functions. Supervisor Christy voiced strong opposition to the arrangement, questioning why, after three years, the position had not been brought in-house.
"After three years, we could find someone who has the capabilities to do this to ensure that it's not being done off a laptop in somebody's private home as opposed to under the supervision of the department," Supervisor Christie argued, highlighting concerns about accountability and data security.
🚗 RTA and Transportation: Paving the Way for Progress
While not a central focus, transportation issues made a brief but significant appearance in the discussions.
Supervisor Rex Scott provided an update on an upcoming RTA Board meeting, stating, "This Thursday is the special meeting of the RTA Board in which we are going to consider a compromise proposal that was crafted by our chair, General Maxwell. It builds on work that Mr. Debonis did with one of his colleagues from the town of Sahuarita. And just based on media comments from some of my colleagues and also some conversations that I've had, I'm cautiously optimistic that we might be able to move towards the public review process."
The meeting also touched on past transportation initiatives, particularly the success of wildlife crossings in garnering support for broader regional plans.
🌈 A Path Forward: Collaboration and Comprehensive Solutions
Despite the contentious nature of many discussions, the meeting also revealed a shared commitment to finding solutions to the complex challenges facing Pima County. Supervisor Lee's call for joint forums with city leadership on homelessness issues and the Board's support for various community development initiatives demonstrate a recognition that these problems require collaborative, multi-faceted approaches.
As we move forward, it's clear that addressing issues like homelessness, public safety, and community development will require not just resources and political will but also a willingness to engage in difficult conversations and challenge our assumptions. The debates in this Board of Supervisors meeting reflect our society's larger struggles in balancing compassion, safety, and fiscal responsibility.
In the words of Chair Grijalva, "The level of stress that we're all, that you see and that we've all expressed is because we all have the same phone calls. We're hearing from businesses, we're hearing from private citizens, we're hearing from people that there's a wash behind their house and there's a fire there every night and, you know, a neighbor's house caught on fire."
As Pima County continues to grapple with these challenges, it's crucial that we, as a community, remain engaged, compassionate, and committed to finding innovative solutions that work for all residents. The path forward may be difficult, but it's one we must walk together.
Voting Record
Resolution 2024-FC4 and Resolution 2024-43 (Multi-Species Conservation Plan): Passed unanimously
Consent Calendar: Passed unanimously
City of Tucson-Pima County Consortium HUD Citizen Participation Plan: Passed 3-1 (Supervisor Christy voting no)
Resolution 2024-52 (Enabling Middle Mile Broadband Grant): Passed 3-1 (Supervisor Christy voting no)
Resolution 2024-49 (Sewer System Revenue Obligations): Passed unanimously
Resolution 2024-50 (Certificates of Participation): Passed unanimously
Resolution 2024-51 (Tohono O'odham Nation State-Shared Revenue Program Funds): Passed unanimously
Surplus Property Items (27 and 28): Passed unanimously
City of Tucson IGA for HUD Consolidated Plan: Passed 3-1 (Supervisor Christyvoting no)
Health Net Access Contract Extension: Passed unanimously
HOPE Inc. Contract Extension: Passed 3-1 (Supervisor Christy voting no)
Thelios LLC Contract Extension: Passed 3-1 (Supervisor Christy voting no)
Items 35-37 (Regional Wastewater Reclamation): Passed unanimously
Items 38-40 (Community Workforce Development Grants): Passed 3-1 (Supervisor Christy voting no)
Items 41-44 (Various Grant Acceptances): Passed unanimously
Liquor License Hearings (Items 46 and 47): Passed unanimously
Resolution 2024-53 (Support for Stop Fentanyl at the Border Act): Passed 3-1 (Supervisor Christy voting no)
Natural Resources, Parks and Recreation Advisory Commission Appointment: Passed unanimously
If you enjoyed this article, buy us a cup of coffee!
