Pima County Board Meeting: Community Voices Demand Change on Critical Issues

A deep dive into community testimonies addressing immigration, environmental justice, and housing crises at the Pima County Board meeting.

😽 Keepin’ It Simple Summary for Younger Readers
👧🏾✊🏾👦🏾

At a big meeting in Pima County 🌞, people talked about how important it is to respect the land 🌍 and its original caretakers 👥. They shared stories about tough issues like immigration 🚪, wildfires 🔥, and the need for more affordable homes 🏘️. Everyone agreed it’s time to not just talk about change 💬, but to take real action ✊ and work together for a better future 🌈 where everyone's voices are heard 📢 and respected.

🗝️ Takeaways

• 🌍 Land Acknowledgment: Acknowledging the ancestral land of tribal nations while questioning true commitments to Indigenous rights.

• 🗣️ Public Testimonies: Community members shared powerful stories about immigration, climate change, and local needs.

• 🔥 Wildfire Management: A push for practical solutions to wildfires, integrating Indigenous fire practices to combat climate change.

• 🏘️ Housing Crisis Highlighted: Urgent need for 116,000 new affordable housing units by 2045 due to pressing economic challenges.

• 🏚️ Homelessness Discussion: Contrasts between bureaucratic efforts and real community experiences regarding homelessness and support systems.

• ✊ Call to Action: Encouraging local participation to challenge injustices and create a more equitable community.

---

Pima County Board of Supervisors: Unmasking Power in the Sonoran Resistance

February 4, 2025: Where Bureaucracy Meets Community Survival

Prologue: The Political Landscape of Occupied Territories

What does democracy look like when it's built on stolen land?

As the February sun cast long shadows across Tohono O'odham and Pascua Yaqui territories, the Pima County Board of Supervisors convened—a microcosm of colonial governance playing out in real time. This isn't just a meeting; it's a battlefield where community survival confronts systemic violence through the mundane language of policy and procedure.

Land Acknowledgement: More Than Performative Rhetoric

The meeting began with a land acknowledgement by Andres Sanchez from Los Amigos Technology Academy, a moment that could have been mere performative gesture but instead rang with potential:

"We honor the tribal nations who have served as caretakers of the land time immemorial... We present Pima County's commitment to diversity and inclusion. We strive to building equal partner relationships with Arizona's tribal nations."

Internal critique: Beautiful words—but will they translate to actual land restitution and Indigenous sovereignty?

Call to the Public: Unfiltered Community Testimony

Voices of Resistance: Immigration and Border Violence

Laurie Moore's testimony epitomized the violent rhetoric of settler colonialism:

"Joe Biden, Alejandro Mayorkas, and the never-present Borders R and DEI hire Kamala Harris ignored our immigration laws. Biden opened the border and funneled billions of dollars to elected officials in blue states and sanctuary cities."

Her demand for a performative "show of hands" revealed the theater of political accountability. This is how white supremacy performs its own legitimacy—through ritualized displays of power.

Supervisor Adelita Grijalva's immediate response was crucial:

"Pima County is committed to diversity, equity and inclusion in our workforce, in our hiring practices, and we will continue to be."

Environmental Justice: Wildfire as Systemic Violence

Joanne Trigo's testimony transformed climate change from abstract policy to immediate survival:

"Climate change is affecting fire seasons. They are now year-round. Wildfires are affecting our flooding and damaged watersheds as they can't absorb, maintain, and or direct moisture."

Each burned acre is a testament to colonial environmental destruction.

Critical Agenda Dissections

1. Wildfire Danger Mitigation: Reactive Power

Supervisor Steve Christie's proposal wasn't just bureaucratic procedure—it was an admission of systemic failure:

"We're getting some moisture now, even though it's been dry, but that moisture leads to growth and that growth leads to dried out vegetation later in the year. And when it's dried out like that, it's like a matchstick."

The plan's key components exposed deeper truths:

• Comprehensive county property evaluation

• Community-level clearing assistance

• Recognition of Indigenous fire management practices

Internal dialogue: How do we move from settler fire management to Indigenous land stewardship?

2. Housing Crisis: Capitalism's Brutal Arithmetic

Tyler Bump's housing needs presentation was a damning indictment of market-driven housing:

• 116,000 new housing units needed by 2045

• Affordability crisis concentrated in lower-income brackets

• Demographic shifts revealing generational economic violence

Bump's stark language: "We're seeing a lot more need in the lower income categories of zero to 60 percent AMI."

Translation: Capitalism continues to render human beings as statistical problems to be "solved."

3. Homelessness: The Bureaucracy of Compassion

The confrontation between Supervisor Christie and homeless services director Jen Darland revealed the profound gap between institutional narrative and community experience:

Christie's pointed questions exposed systemic failures:

• What are the actual costs of current interventions?

• How are we measuring true success beyond temporary shelter?

• What accountability exists for repeated criminal behaviors?

Darland's response attempted compassion but remained trapped in institutional language.

Votes as Political Performance

• Cell Tower Denial: 4-1 (Christie dissenting) A rare victory of community landscape preservation over corporate infrastructure

• Wildfire Mitigation Plan: Unanimous support Performative solidarity or genuine commitment?

• Fire District Funding: Unanimous Recognizing the underfunded frontline of community protection

• Fireworks Permits: 3-2 split Even minor permissions reveal political fractures

Deeper Connections: Beyond this Meeting

This isn't just local governance—it's a microcosm of broader struggles:

• Immigration policy as continued colonial violence

• Environmental destruction as systemic racism

• Housing as a fundamental human right, not a market commodity

Call to Radical Community Action

1. Attend every local government meeting

2. Document and amplify marginalized testimonies

3. Build solidarity networks across community organizations

4. Challenge every bureaucratic narrative

5. Organize, never compromise

The revolution is local. The revolution is now.

Reader Engagement

We want to hear from YOU!

Drop a comment below and answer TWO of these critical questions:

1. How do you see local policy impacting your daily life?

2. What community issues are most urgent in your neighborhood?

3. How can we build more inclusive, responsive local governance?

¡La lucha continúa! The struggle continues!

Solidarity is a verb. Act now.

Transparency Note

This report is an act of political witnessing. Every governmental proceeding is a potential site of resistance.

¡La lucha continúa! The struggle continues!

---

Voices of Power and Resistance: Quotes that Reveal Systemic Truths

Immigration and Border Politics

• Laurie Moore (Constituent):

"Biden opened the border and funneled billions of dollars to elected officials in blue states and sanctuary cities. Millions of illegal immigrants were lured here. [...] This act, in the name of humanity, has become a crime against humanity." Context: Call to the Public, expressing xenophobic rhetoric about immigration policies

• Adelita Grijalva (Supervisor, responding to anti-DEI comments):

"Pima County is committed to diversity, equity and inclusion in our workforce, in our hiring practices, and we will continue to be." Context: Direct pushback against racist rhetoric during the meeting

Wildfire and Environmental Justice

• Joanne Trigo (Tangerine Valley Association):

"Climate change is affecting fire seasons. They are now year-round. Wildfires are affecting our flooding and damaged watersheds as they can't absorb, maintain, and or direct moisture." Context: Highlighting the critical intersection of climate change and community survival

• Steve Christy (Supervisor, on wildfire risks):

"This season is going to be ripe for wildfires. All indications say that it is. We're getting some moisture now, even though it's been dry, but that moisture leads to growth and that growth leads to dried out vegetation later in the year. And when it's dried out like that, it's like a matchstick." Context: Proposing comprehensive wildfire mitigation plan

Housing and Community Survival

• Tyler Bump (ECOnorthwest Housing Consultant):

"We're seeing a lot more need in the lower income categories of zero to 60 percent AMI." Context: Presenting housing needs assessment, exposing economic inequality

Homelessness and Community Services

• Supervisor Christy (challenging homeless services):

"What is the cost per recipient? Success is being defined as getting people back on their feet, not simply supporting them with a roof over their head." Context: Demanding accountability in homeless services

Comprehensive People Breakdown

Pima County Board of Supervisors

1. Rex Scott (Chair)

   • Role: Meeting Chair, primary decision-maker

   • Memorable Quote: Supported releasing confidential memo about federal law enforcement

2. Adelita Grijalva

   • Role: Supervisor, strong advocate for diversity and inclusion

   • Notable Action: Directly challenged anti-immigrant and anti-DEI rhetoric

   • Memorable Quote: Reaffirmed county's commitment to diversity

3. Steve Christy (District 4)

   • Role: Supervisor, proposed wildfire mitigation plan

   • Key Contributions:

     • Pushed for comprehensive wildfire prevention

     • Critically questioned homeless services effectiveness

   • Memorable Quote: Described dry vegetation as "like a matchstick"

4. Jennifer Allen (District 3)

   • Role: Supervisor, key in cell tower permit denial

   • Memorable Quote: Emphasized preserving landscape beauty

   • Notable Vote: Led opposition to cell tower permit

5. Matt Heinz (District 2)

   • Role: Supervisor, proposed fire district funding legislation

   • Key Contribution: Highlighted rural fire protection gaps

   • Memorable Quote: Described areas with no fire protection response capability

Key Administrators

1. Carmine DeBonis

   • Role: Deputy County Administrator

   • Notable Action: Provided technical context for various agenda items

2. Jen Darland

   • Role: Director of Housing Solutions and Homeless Services

   • Challenged By: Supervisor Christie on service effectiveness

3. Maddie Vasquez

   • Role: Senior Advisor to County Administration

   • Emerging Influence: Brought fire mitigation expertise

Community Voices

1. Laurie Moore

   • Role: Constituent, delivered anti-immigrant testimony

   • Perspective: Represents xenophobic border politics rhetoric

2. Joanne Trigo

   • Role: Tangerine Valley Association officer

   • Contribution: Powerful testimony on climate change and wildfire risks

3. Tyler Bump

   • Role: ECOnorthwest Consultant

   • Key Contribution: Presented comprehensive housing needs assessment

---

---

☕ If you enjoyed this article, give us a tip! We 🤎☕‼️

---