💧 From Waste to Taste: Arizona's Bold Water Recycling Plan
🔬 The Science Behind ADEQ's Decision-Making 🚰 Advanced Water Purification: A Thirsty State's Salvation? 🏜️ Mining in the Desert: Navigating Environmental Challenges
Based on the 10/01/24 on KVOI-1030AM.
🙊 Notable quotes from the show
Amanda Stone: "We have over 20,000 regulated facilities and activities in the state." (Context: Explaining the scope of ADEQ's responsibilities)
Trevor Bajori: "If a facility meets the legal requirements, we're required by law to issue the aquifer protection permit, for example." (Context: Discussing the limitations of ADEQ's discretionary power)
Randy Modus: "When you look at the types of treatment and the amount of treatment and the rigor of the program proposed so far, you can see how this technology, when deployed, will not only treat water to be in full compliance with the State Drinking Water Act but oftentimes will actually provide water that far exceeds the quality you typically find with other potable water sources." (Context: Explaining the potential benefits of Advanced Water Purification)
Amanda Stone: "We've not been involved in the whole federal fast processing, that doesn't really impact us, our delegated authority is very clear, and as I said earlier, it's fairly prescriptive, so that hasn't really impacted us or our decision making." (Context: Clarifying ADEQ's role in federal processes like Fast 42 for mining projects)
⏮️ ICYMI: From the Last Show…
😽 Keepin’ It Simple Summary for Younger Readers
👧🏾✊🏾👦🏾
🌵🏭💧 The Arizona Department of Environmental Quality (ADEQ) works hard to keep our air clean, water safe, and land healthy! They make sure companies follow rules to protect nature. 🌟 ADEQ is working on a cool new way to clean water so we have enough to drink. They ask people what they think about their ideas. 🗣️ ADEQ tries to balance helping businesses and protecting the environment. It's like a big puzzle they solve every day! 🧩 They use science to make good choices. Remember, we all play a part in keeping Arizona beautiful! 🌅
🗝️ Takeaways
🏢 ADEQ regulates over 20,000 facilities to protect Arizona's environment
💼 The agency balances environmental protection with economic development
🗳️ Public input is valued, but decisions are ultimately guided by laws and regulations
💧 Advanced Water Purification could provide a new source of high-quality drinking water
🤝 ADEQ often goes beyond minimum requirements for community engagement
🔬 Science-based decision-making is at the core of ADEQ's approach
📻 What They Discussed
On October 1, 2024, Ted Maxwell hosted "Jump in Tucson: The Engagement Hour" on 1030 The Voice, featuring three key Arizona Department of Environmental Quality (ADEQ) leaders. The guests were
Amanda Stone, Deputy Director of ADEQ and Intergovernmental and Community Outreach Director;
Trevor Bajori, Director of ADEQ's Water Quality Division, and
Randy Modus, Water Quality Division Deputy Director.
These seasoned professionals, each with over two decades of experience in environmental regulation, provided listeners with an in-depth look at ADEQ's operations, challenges, and future initiatives.
🏢 ADEQ's Role in Protecting Arizona's Environment
The Arizona Department of Environmental Quality (ADEQ) is the state's primary environmental regulatory agency, overseeing more than 20,000 regulated facilities and activities. With an approximately 570-person staff, ADEQ's mandate spans a wide range of environmental concerns, from air and water quality to waste management and environmental cleanup.
Amanda Stone explained that ADEQ's regulatory structure is primarily based on federal laws such as the Clean Air Act and Clean Water Act, which the agency is delegated to implement in Arizona. However, ADEQ also enforces state-specific regulations, like the Aquifer Protection Permit program. This dual approach allows the agency to address national environmental standards and Arizona's unique ecological challenges.
The agency's responsibilities include issuing permits, conducting inspections, ensuring compliance, and engaging with communities affected by environmental decisions. ADEQ strives to balance environmental protection with economic development, operating within a framework of laws and regulations that can sometimes limit its discretionary power.
🌊 Water Quality Management and Permitting Process
Trevor Bajori provided insights into ADEQ's water quality management efforts, particularly the permitting process for facilities that could impact water resources. Using the example of an Aquifer Protection Permit for a mining facility, Bajori outlined the steps involved:
Initial consultations with potential applicants
Pre-application meetings to review draft applications
Formal application submission and technical review
Public comment periods and community engagement
Final decision-making based on legal and regulatory requirements
Bajori emphasized that while ADEQ values public input, its decisions are ultimately guided by established laws and regulations. The agency aims to provide transparency and opportunities for community involvement throughout the process but must operate within its legal mandate.
👥 Community Engagement and Public Participation
A recurring theme throughout the discussion was ADEQ's commitment to community engagement. The agency often exceeds the minimum legal requirements for public input, recognizing the importance of local knowledge and concerns in environmental decision-making. Amanda Stone highlighted several initiatives:
Early community engagement efforts before formal public comment periods
Public meetings and notices to inform residents about proposed projects
Community science programs, such as surface water sampling near mining operations
These efforts aim to build trust, increase transparency, and strengthen permit conditions based on community input. However, the guests acknowledged the challenges in balancing diverse stakeholder interests and the limitations imposed by regulatory frameworks.
🏭 Mining Operations and Environmental Concerns
The discussion touched on the contentious issue of mining operations in Arizona, particularly referencing the South 32 project. Amanda Stone acknowledged the high community interest and concerns surrounding such projects. She explained that while ADEQ's role is limited to its specific regulatory authority, the agency strives to address community concerns where possible.
ADEQ has implemented additional measures for projects like South 32, including:
Extended public comment periods
Voluntary additions to permits beyond minimum regulatory requirements
Support for community-led environmental monitoring programs
These efforts aim to provide additional assurances to the community while operating within ADEQ's legal mandate. However, the discussion highlighted the ongoing challenges in balancing economic development with environmental protection and community concerns.
💧 Advanced Water Purification: Innovating for Arizona's Water Future
Randy Modus introduced listeners to ADEQ's ongoing rulemaking process for Advanced Water Purification, a promising technology that could help address Arizona's water scarcity issues. This initiative aims to allow direct potable reuse of treated wastewater, potentially providing a new source of high-quality drinking water for Arizona communities.
The rulemaking process, which began in June 2022, has involved:
Formation of a technical advisory group comprising engineers, scientists, regulators, and utilities
Development of an Advanced Water Purification roadmap
Multiple rounds of public and stakeholder comments
Drafting and revising proposed rules
Modus emphasized the rigorous nature of this process, which has included extensive research into best practices from other states and countries. The proposed rules aim to ensure that any advanced water purification systems meet or exceed current drinking water standards.
This initiative represents a significant step in water resource management for Arizona, potentially offering a sustainable solution to water scarcity while maintaining high standards for public health and safety.
🔬 Science-Based Decision-Making in Environmental Regulation
Throughout the discussion, all three ADEQ leaders emphasized the agency's reliance on scientific data and technical expertise in its decision-making processes. This approach is evident in:
The rigorous technical reviews conducted during the permitting
The use of community science programs to gather water quality data
The engagement of technical advisory groups in rulemaking processes
By grounding its decisions in science, ADEQ aims to ensure that its regulations and permits effectively protect Arizona's environment while allowing for responsible economic development. However, the guests also acknowledged the challenges in communicating complex scientific and regulatory concepts to the public.
🌱 Balancing Environmental Protection and Economic Development
An underlying theme throughout the discussion was the delicate balance ADEQ must maintain between protecting Arizona's environment and supporting economic growth. The guests emphasized that ADEQ's role is not to decide whether a project should proceed but to ensure that any development meets established environmental standards.
This balancing act involves:
Working within established legal and regulatory frameworks
Providing clear guidance to businesses on environmental requirements
Engaging with communities to address concerns and gather local knowledge
Implementing innovative solutions, like advanced water purification, to address resource challenges
The discussion highlighted the complex interplay between environmental protection, economic interests, community concerns, and regulatory limitations that ADEQ must navigate in its decision-making processes.
🦉 Three Sonorans Commentary
¡Atención, comunidad! Today, we dive into the complex world of environmental regulation in Arizona, where the machinations of capitalism and settler colonialism often blur the lines between protection and exploitation.
The recent Jump in Tucson radio show featuring leaders from the Arizona Department of Environmental Quality (ADEQ) raised critical questions about environmental justice, water rights, and the ongoing struggle between corporate interests and community well-being.
Water Wars and Corporate Interests
In our sun-baked state, water is life. While innovative, ADEQ's Advanced Water Purification initiative must be scrutinized through the lens of historical injustice. For millennia, Indigenous communities were stewards of these precious water sources, only to see them exploited and polluted by colonial interests.
As Trevor Bajori explained the permitting process, one can't help but wonder: how many sacred sites and ancestral lands have been sacrificed at the altar of "economic development"? The proposed direct potable wastewater reuse is a band-aid solution to a problem created by unchecked growth and corporate water grabs.
Amanda Stone's assurance that "there's a lot of opportunities for engagement with the agency" rings hollow when we consider the long history of environmental injustice faced by communities of color and Indigenous peoples. Genuine engagement means more than just listening – prioritizing the voices of those most affected by environmental degradation.
Mining: A Toxic Legacy Continues
The discussion of mining permits, particularly the South 32 project, highlights the ongoing struggle between environmental protection and resource extraction. ADEQ's "balance" between industry and community interests often tips for corporations with deep pockets and armies of lawyers.
Trevor Bajori's statement that "If a facility meets the legal requirements, we're required by law to issue the aquifer protection permit" exposes the limitations of current environmental laws. Often written to benefit industry, these laws fail to protect our communities and ecosystems adequately.
The Community Science Conundrum
While ADEQ touts its community science programs, we must ask: is this genuine empowerment or a neoliberal tactic to shift responsibility? While seemingly progressive, these programs place the burden of monitoring on citizens rather than holding polluters accountable.
Decolonizing Environmental Protection
As we face the existential threat of climate change and ongoing environmental degradation, we need more than just regulatory agencies – we need a fundamental shift in how we relate to the land and its resources. This means:
Centering Indigenous knowledge and sovereignty in environmental decision-making
Prioritizing environmental justice for communities of color and low-income areas
Challenging the capitalist paradigm that views nature as a resource to be exploited
Implementing truly democratic processes for environmental planning and regulation
ADEQ's efforts, while well-intentioned, operate within a system designed to prioritize profit over people and the planet. As Arizonans committed to social and environmental justice, we must demand more than technical solutions – we need a radical reimagining of our relationship with the environment.
¡La lucha sigue, compañeros! The fight for environmental justice is inseparable from our broader struggles against racism, capitalism, and colonialism. Let us continue to raise our voices, organize our communities, and demand a future where our people and planet's health takes precedence over corporate profits.
If you enjoyed this article, buy us a cup of coffee! We 🤎☕‼️
👯 People Mentioned
Ted Maxwell: Host of Jump in Tucson, The Engagement Hour. Member of the Arizona State Transportation Board.
Amanda Stone: Deputy Director of ADEQ and Intergovernmental and Community Outreach Director. Over 30 years of experience with ADEQ. Quote: "It's really been a pleasure speaking with you today, and I just want for your folks that are listening to know that there's a lot of opportunities for engagement with the agency, and we'd welcome that engagement."
Trevor Bajori: Director of ADEQ's Water Quality Division. With ADEQ since 2001. Quote: "The public, of course, can help make sure that all of the work that we have done meets the requirements of law."
Randy Modus: Water Quality Division Deputy Director since 2015. Over 19 years with ADEQ. Quote: "This rule doesn't require any utility to do anything, it provides them another option where if they look at their source water portfolio and this looks like a good option for them, they're able to get this advanced water purification permit."
Matt Neely: Behind-the-scenes producer for the radio show.
 | A guest post by
|