🔥 First Americans vs. Foreign Mining Giants: Apache Chairman Schools Trump on Real Patriotism, Oak Flat Wins Temporary Victory That Angers President

⛰️ Sacred Land, Chinese Gold: The $160 Billion Giveaway Trump Calls "American." Why defending Indigenous holy sites from foreign corporations suddenly makes you "anti-American"

😽 Keepin’ It Simple Summary for Younger Readers
👧🏾✊🏾👦🏾

There's a special place in Arizona 🏜️ called Oak Flat where Apache families have held sacred ceremonies for thousands of years ✨⛺, kind of like their most important church ⛪.

Some big companies from other countries (especially China 🇨🇳) want to dig a huge hole ⛏️ there to get copper metal 🪙, which would completely destroy this holy place 🙏 and use up lots of water 💧 that desert communities need.

When judges ⚖️ said "wait, let's think about this more carefully," the President 🇺🇸 got really angry 😡 and called the Apache people "anti-American" – even though they're the original Americans 🪶 and the mining companies are actually owned by China!

The Apache leaders pointed out how silly 🤦 this was, since the President had just met 🤝 with these foreign mining bosses at the White House 🏛️. Now three different groups of lawyers 👩‍⚖️👨‍⚖️ are fighting in court to protect this sacred place 🏞️, and most Americans agree 👍 the holy land should be saved ❤️ instead of destroyed for foreign companies 💼💰 to make money.

---

🗝️ Takeaways

• 🚨 Court Victory: 9th Circuit temporarily blocked land transfer of 2,400 acres of sacred Apache land to Chinese-owned mining corporations

• ⚖️ Presidential Hypocrisy: Trump called mine opponents "anti-American" hours after hosting Rio Tinto and BHP CEOs at the White House

• 🇨🇳 Foreign Ownership: Chinalco (Chinese company) is the largest shareholder of Rio Tinto; all copper will be shipped to China for processing

• 💸 Corporate Welfare: Mining companies will extract $160 billion in copper while paying virtually no royalties to American taxpayers

• 🏛️ Legal Strategy: Three separate lawsuits challenge land swap, including a new case by Apache women citing parental religious rights

• 🤝 Broad Coalition: 21 of 22 Arizona tribal nations, faith communities, and 74% of Americans oppose the mine

• 💧 Environmental Destruction: The proposed mine would create a 2-mile crater, pump massive groundwater, and contaminate desert water sources

• 👑 Tribal Leadership: Chairman Terry Rambler and Dr. Wendsler Nosie Sr. expose Trump's "misinformation" while defending sacred sites

• 📅 Timeline: Court gave parties until October 14 for legal responses; 60-day emergency injunction provides temporary protection

• 💪 Resistance Continues: Apache Stronghold and allies maintain grassroots organizing despite corporate and political pressure

---

✊🏽 Fifteen Years Strong - Help Three Sonorans Keep Telling Our Stories!

---

Sacred Ground Under Siege: When Standing with Indigenous Rights Gets You Called "Anti-American"

🗝️ Takeaways

• 🚨 Court Victory: 9th Circuit temporarily blocked land transfer of 2,400 acres of sacred Apache land to Chinese-owned mining corporations

• ⚖️ Presidential Hypocrisy: Trump called mine opponents "anti-American" hours after hosting Rio Tinto and BHP CEOs at the White House

• 🇨🇳 Foreign Ownership: Chinalco (Chinese company) is the largest shareholder of Rio Tinto; all copper will be shipped to China for processing

• 💸 Corporate Welfare: Mining companies will extract $160 billion in copper while paying virtually no royalties to American taxpayers

• 🏛️ Legal Strategy: Three separate lawsuits challenge land swap, including a new case by Apache women citing parental religious rights

• 🤝 Broad Coalition: 21 of 22 Arizona tribal nations, faith communities, and 74% of Americans oppose the mine

• 💧 Environmental Destruction: The proposed mine would create a 2-mile crater, pump massive groundwater, and contaminate desert water sources

• 👑 Tribal Leadership: Chairman Terry Rambler and Dr. Wendsler Nosie Sr. expose Trump's "misinformation" while defending sacred sites

• 📅 Timeline: Court gave parties until October 14 for legal responses; 60-day emergency injunction provides temporary protection

• 💪 Resistance Continues: Apache Stronghold and allies maintain grassroots organizing despite corporate and political pressure

¿Cómo estás, mi gente? Let me pour myself some strong cafecito this afternoon because we've got some heavy chingaderas to unpack about what's happening at Oak Flat.

Just this week, we witnessed something that would be laughable if it weren't so damn dangerous.

After the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals temporarily blocked a federal land swap that would hand over 2,400 acres of sacred Apache land to Resolution Copper—a foreign mining company owned by Rio Tinto and BHP—President Trump took to Truth Social to call the court's decision the work of a "radical left court" and labeled opponents of the mine as "anti-American."

Órale, let that sink in. Standing with Indigenous people to protect their sacred sites is now "anti-American." The irony is so thick you could cut it with a machete.

The Background: A Sacred Place Under Threat

For those just tuning in to this ongoing nightmare, let me break down what's at stake here.

Oak Flat, known to the Apache as Chi'chil Biłdagoteel, sits in the Tonto National Forest about 40 miles east of Phoenix. This isn't just any piece of desert—it's a sacred site dotted with ancient Emory oak groves where Apache families have conducted coming-of-age ceremonies, gathered traditional foods and medicines, and maintained spiritual connections for countless generations.

But according to Resolution Copper and their political enablers, all of this cultura and spiritual tradition should be sacrificed so they can create a crater "up to two miles wide and 1,000 feet deep" to extract copper that will likely be shipped overseas for processing.

According to environmental advocates, this mining technique would pump massive amounts of groundwater, deplete surface waters, and threaten water availability across the entire region.

¿En serio? We're talking about sacrificing irreplaceable sacred land and precious water resources in the desert Southwest so a foreign corporation can profit from copper that will end up in Chinese smelters. But somehow, opposing this extractive colonialism makes us the anti-American ones.

The Court Decision: A Temporary Victory

The 9th Circuit's emergency injunction came just hours before the land was scheduled to be transferred on August 19th.

This temporary reprieve gives the courts time to review three ongoing lawsuits challenging the land exchange—one filed by the San Carlos Apache Tribe, another by a coalition of environmental groups, and a third by Apache women asserting their rights to raise their children according to their religious traditions.

The decision represents years of tireless organizing by Apache Stronghold, led by former San Carlos Apache Tribal Chairman Dr. Wendsler Nosie Sr., who has literally lived on the land to protect it. Russ McSpadden from the Center for Biological Diversity captured the moment perfectly: "Everyone who loves Oak Flat and who's been fighting for years to save it can exhale for now."

But this is just a pause, not a victory. The injunction only lasts 60 days while the legal challenges proceed.

Trump's Tantrum: Doubling Down on Extraction

Rather than respecting the judicial process—you know, that separation of powers thing that's supposedly fundamental to democracy—Trump immediately took to social media to attack the court and anyone standing with the Apache people.

In his Truth Social post on August 19th, hours after meeting with the CEOs of Rio Tinto and BHP at the White House, Trump didn't just attack the "Radical Left Court"—he escalated to calling mine opponents "Anti-American, and representing other Copper competitive Countries."

The audacity is breathtaking.

Trump claims those defending Indigenous sacred sites are somehow working for foreign copper interests, while literally meeting with executives from foreign mining corporations in the Oval Office.

As Reuters reported, BHP CEO Mike Henry thanked Trump "for their strong leadership to reinvigorate mining and processing supply chains in and for America" right after their White House meeting.

But here's the chingadera that really gets me: Trump's accusation that mine opponents are helping China, when the largest shareholder of Rio Tinto is literally Chinalco—a Chinese company.

With only three copper smelters in the U.S. (and one currently non-functional), this copper will be shipped straight to China for processing. So we're talking about destroying sacred Indigenous land and depleting precious water resources to help Chinese-owned corporations export raw materials to China.

¿Pero cómo? How exactly does that make America stronger or more secure?

The Real "Anti-Americans": Corporate Colonizers

Let's talk about who the real "anti-Americans" are in this story.

We have Rio Tinto and BHP—two multinational mining giants with horrific track records of environmental destruction and human rights violations around the world. These are companies that have poisoned rivers, displaced communities, and enriched shareholders while leaving behind toxic wastelands.

Democratic congressional candidate Adelita Grijalva didn't mince words when she called Trump's interference "reckless," "dangerous," and "corrupt," accusing him of trying to "strong-arm the court" and undermine the judicial process.

But here's what really gets me fired up: the framing of Indigenous resistance as somehow un-American. San Carlos Apache Tribe Chairman Terry Rambler's response cut through Trump's bullshit with surgical precision:

"As first Americans, the San Carlos Apache Tribe agrees on the importance of protecting America's interests, but the President's comments mirror misinformation that has been repeated by foreign mining interests that want to extract American copper."

¡Órale! Chairman Rambler just delivered a master class in how to respond to colonial gaslighting. He pointed out that Chinalco, a Chinese company, is the largest shareholder of Rio Tinto, and noted the obvious: "Of course, their interest is in mining this copper and shipping it to China."

Dr. Wendsler Nosie Sr. responded with the dignity and wisdom that has characterized this entire struggle: "Our nation cannot survive if we sacrifice what is sacred in pursuit of temporary profits."

Think about that for a moment. Indigenous peoples—the original Americans, the ones who have stewarded this land for millennia—are being called anti-American for defending their sacred sites from foreign corporate interests.

The level of colonial gaslighting here is breathtaking.

Environmental Justice in the Borderlands

As someone living in the frontera of Southern Arizona, I see this fight as part of a larger pattern of environmental racism that treats Indigenous communities, communities of color, and border regions as sacrifice zones for corporate profit. From uranium mining on Navajo lands to toxic waste dumps in predominantly Latino neighborhoods, the message is clear: some lives and some places matter less than others.

The ecological destruction at Oak Flat would extend far beyond the immediate mining site. We're talking about endangered species like ocelots and Arizona hedgehog cacti, the destruction of riparian forests and springs, and the contamination of groundwater that countless desert communities depend on.

In a region already facing unprecedented drought and water scarcity, pumping "massive amounts of groundwater" for a foreign copper mine isn't just environmentally destructive—it's pendejada of the highest order.

The Spiritual Dimension: More Than Politics

But this fight goes deeper than environmental or economic concerns. For Apache families, Oak Flat isn't just a place—it's the foundation of their spiritual practice and cultural survival.

The site is where young Apache women undergo their traditional coming-of-age ceremonies, where families gather traditional foods and medicines, and where the connection between past, present, and future generations is maintained.

As Nosie explained in his response to Trump: "This is a fight about our identity as a nation. Do we respect religious freedom? Will we safeguard our environment for our children and grandchildren? Or will we sacrifice it all for corporate greed?"

The beauty of this movement is how it has brought together people across faith traditions—Catholics, Protestants, Muslims, Jews, and Indigenous spiritual practitioners—all united in the understanding that some things are more sacred than profit margins.

Legal Strategies and Congressional Complicity

The legal path to this moment reveals the depths of political corruption that enabled this crisis.

Back in 2014, Senators John McCain and Jeff Flake slipped a last-minute provision into a military spending bill authorizing the Oak Flat land swap. McCain, who received $7,500 in campaign contributions from Rio Tinto, argued that Apache leaders had stated Oak Flat "is not a sacred site"—a claim that was both false and deeply insulting to Apache communities.

This is how extractive colonialism works in the modern era: corporate money flows to politicians, legislation gets crafted in back rooms and attached to must-pass bills, and Indigenous voices get erased from the conversation entirely.

Apache Stronghold has been fighting in federal court since 2021, arguing that the land transfer violates the Religious Freedom Restoration Act and the Apache's constitutional rights to religious freedom and due process. The Supreme Court rejected their initial appeal in May, but the legal battle continues with three separate lawsuits now proceeding through the 9th Circuit.

The newest lawsuit, filed by Apache women in July, leverages recent Supreme Court rulings affirming parental rights to direct their children's religious education.

As Chairman Rambler noted, the mining companies "will dig up $160 billion in copper and, under current law, pay almost no royalties." This proposed mine, he said, "is a rip-off, will destroy a sacred area, decimates our environment, threatens our water rights, and is bad for America."

Building Intersectional Solidarity

What gives me hope is seeing how this struggle has inspired solidarity across communities that don't always work together. Environmental groups, religious organizations, rock climbers, tribal nations, and immigrant rights activists have all found common ground in defending Oak Flat.

This is the kind of solidaridad we need to build more of—recognition that attacks on Indigenous sovereignty, environmental destruction, and corporate colonialism affect all of our communities.

When multinational corporations can override sacred Indigenous sites with impunity, when foreign mining companies can deplete our water resources for private profit, when politicians can criminalize resistance to environmental racism—all of our freedoms are under threat.

Hope in the Resistance

Despite Trump's tantrums and corporate pressure, this movement has achieved something remarkable. Public polls show that 74% of Americans support protecting Oak Flat, and the broad coalition defending the site includes 21 of the 22 federally recognized tribal nations in Arizona, the National Congress of American Indians, and dozens of faith communities.

This isn't just about stopping one mine—it's about asserting a different vision of what America could be. A country that honors Indigenous sovereignty instead of criminalizing it. A society that prioritizes spiritual and ecological values over short-term corporate profits. A democracy where "We the People" includes the original peoples of this land.

The Path Forward: Organizing for Justice

So what can we do? First, stay informed and stay engaged. This fight is far from over, and the legal challenges will need sustained community support.

Support organizations like Apache Stronghold that are leading this struggle. Follow their work and amplify their voices rather than speaking for them.

Contact your representatives and demand they stand with Indigenous rights over corporate interests. Make it clear that destroying sacred sites for foreign mining profits isn't patriotic—it's colonial violence.

Build connections between environmental justice, Indigenous sovereignty, and immigrant rights struggles in your own communities. These fights are connected, and our resistance needs to be connected too.

And remember that this is about more than politics—it's about the kind of world we want to leave for our children and grandchildren. As Dr. Nosie reminds us: "By protecting Oak Flat, we protect our children and grandchildren, protect Mother Earth, and protect everything that is sacred."

Ese Trump can call us anti-American all he wants. We know that standing with Indigenous peoples against corporate colonialism is the most American thing we can do. After all, this land belonged to Indigenous communities long before foreign mining companies showed up with their extraction fantasies.

The real anti-Americans are the ones willing to sacrifice sacred sites, poison our water, and sell out our sovereignty for a few pieces of copper. We see them clearly now, and we're not backing down.

¡La lucha sigue! The struggle continues, and so does our hope for justice.

---

Support Three Sonorans Substack to stay informed about environmental justice and Indigenous rights struggles in the borderlands and beyond. Your subscription helps us continue this critical coverage.

What are your thoughts on this ongoing struggle? Leave a comment below with two questions related to Oak Flat, Indigenous sovereignty, or environmental justice that you'd like us to explore in future coverage.

---

---

Have a scoop or a story you want us to follow up on? Send us a message!

---

---