🏰 Castles & Capitalism: Inside Ireland's Transformation from Homeland to Playground for the Wealthy | BUCKMASTER SHOW
When "hundreds, not thousands" becomes code for class exclusivity on the high seas
Based on the Buckmaster Show for 5/15/25, a daily radio show in Tucson, AZ, interviewing local newsmakers. Analysis and opinions are my own.
😽 Keepin’ It Simple Summary for Younger Readers
👧🏾✊🏾👦🏾
🎙️ The 📻 Bill Buckmaster show did a 🌟 special episode about 💰 fancy travel. The 🗣️ host was on 🏝️ vacation in Hawaii 🏨 and called in to describe 🏖️ beautiful beaches and 🌄 lookout points. Then they talked to a 👩 woman from 🍀 Ireland who described 🏰 castles where you can stay and do things like 🦅 hold hawks on your arm. Finally, they talked about 🚢 cruise ships that have 👥 fewer people and lots of 👨🍳 chefs making 🍽️ fancy food.
🗝️ Takeaways
🏝️ Bill Buckmaster called in from Hawaii's Four Seasons Oahu, recommending hidden gems like Lanikai Beach and Tantalus Lookout State Park
🍀 Emma Power from Brendan Vacations painted Ireland as a postcard-perfect destination where "authentic" experiences can be purchased through their exclusive network of local specialists
🏰 Ashford Castle emerged as the epitome of luxury tourism in Ireland, offering activities like falconry and walks with Irish Wolfhounds—medieval pastimes now repackaged as premium experiences for wealthy visitors
🚢 Oceania Cruises positions itself as superior to mass-market lines by emphasizing exclusivity ("sailing with hundreds, not thousands") and gourmet dining with a ratio of one chef for every ten guests
Buckmaster's Travel Odyssey: Privilege, Paradise, and the Paradox of Modern Tourism
In an era when the ultra-wealthy rocket themselves to the edge of space for ten-minute joyrides, the Bill Buckmaster Show took listeners on a different kind of journey this week. Ryan Hansen of Bon Voyage Travel commandeered the captain's chair while regular host Bill Buckmaster called in from the lap of luxury in Hawaii. He traded his familiar studio for the Four Seasons Oahu, where even the rainbows appeared on cue for the well-heeled visitor.
The show transformed into an hour-long advertisement for aspirational tourism that would make late-stage capitalism blush with pride. Yet beneath the glittering veneer of exclusive experiences and five-star accommodations lay unintentional commentary on class, environmental impact, and the complex ethics of modern travel—a subtext as rich as the Kona coffee Buckmaster was presumably sipping while describing Hawaii's "perfect" weather.
Postcards from Paradise: Buckmaster's Hawaiian Holiday
"The air here is just incredible. It's so special," Buckmaster rhapsodized over the phone line, his voice carrying the intoxicating lightness of someone who's temporarily escaped the weight of American reality. "You're sitting 3,000 miles from the North American continent... so bottom line: air pollution; it just doesn't exist here."
Buckmaster revealed that Lanikai Beach on Oahu's eastern "Windward" side represents peak Hawaiian paradise, despite its location on the most tourist-trampled of the Hawaiian islands.
"A lot of people would say, 'oh my gosh, you mean the best beach in the Hawaiian Islands is on Oahu? I thought it would be Maui or Kauai,'" Buckmaster said. "Well, guess what? It is Lanikai Beach, voted as one of the three best beaches in the world."
Buckmaster then dropped what he clearly considered the ultimate celebrity endorsement: "And guess who just moved in? Former President Obama has switched beach houses, and he's now right on the beach."
The regular host also suggested listeners check out Tantalus Lookout State Park for its panoramic views. His accommodations journey began at the Royal Hawaiian, which he praised as "the quintessential Waikiki Honolulu experience" that "just screams of old Hawaii.”
"When you have that kind of image in your mind for the rest of your life," Buckmaster said about watching the full moon over Waikiki, "how do you put a price on that, sir?"
The Emerald Isle Experience: Ireland Without the Irish Problems
The show's middle segment transported listeners across the Pacific and Atlantic to the rolling hills of Ireland. Emma Power of Brendan Vacations called in from Dublin to paint a portrait of Ireland that conveniently airbrushed out any hint of the country's complex socioeconomic reality.
Power described Ireland and Scotland as lands where "around every corner, there's another ancient ruin, a local pub, green pastures, as far as the eye can see, and wildlife going about their daily business"—a description so picture-perfect it could have been AI-generated for a tourism brochure. This description left listeners wondering if real Irish people with real Irish problems even exist in this pastoral fantasy.
The conversation quickly pivoted to highlighting how Brendan Vacations offers privileged access to "our little black book of only the best local specialists." Power described visits with a woman named Tracy Jeffery near Belfast who welcomes travelers into her farmhouse for bread-making workshops—transforming everyday Irish domestic labor into a commodified experience for wealthy tourists.
"It's such a unique opportunity to experience an authentic Irish home," Power enthused, seemingly unaware of the inherent contradiction in marketing "authenticity" as a purchasable experience.
Nothing says "authentic" quite like paying strangers to let you pretend you're part of their daily life for an afternoon.
The crescendo of this Irish tourism symphony came with extended discussion of Ashford Castle, a 13th-century structure now transformed into a luxury hotel that costs more per night than the average Irish worker makes in a week.
"It's another absolute must for anyone visiting Ireland," Power insisted, conveniently forgetting that "anyone" in this context means "anyone with several thousand dollars to burn on accommodation."
Ryan Hansen, having just returned from his own stay at this feudal fantasy land, couldn't contain his aristocratic glee: "I was told room 414 is the Rory McElroy suite, which means every time Rory comes to Ashford, which he comes often, that's the room he stays in."
Because nothing connects you to the authentic spirit of Ireland like sleeping in the same bed as a multi-millionaire golfer.
Hansen described the castle's falconry school as "truly an unforgettable experience where we had the Harrison Hawks landing on our arms." One imagines medieval Irish peasants would have found this recreational use of hunting birds equally unforgettable, though for entirely different reasons.
Floating Enclaves: Oceania's Exclusive Waterways
For the final segment, Scott Kluzner from Oceania Cruises completed the trifecta of luxury tourism by extolling the virtues of small-ship cruising where guests travel "with hundreds, not thousands" of their fellow affluent voyagers.
"With Oceania, you're only sailing with hundreds, not thousands," Kluzner explained, selling exclusivity as the ultimate luxury. "There's no lines. There's no waiting. It's easy to get on and off. We describe it as a country club casual atmosphere on board."
Because nothing says "getting away from it all" quite like recreating the stratified social environment of an American country club, but on water.
Hansen helpfully contextualized the difference between Oceania and mass-market cruise lines: "You're talking three, four, 5,000 of your closest friends sailing with you. But boy, the difference is, to me, is very stark when you get to that more intimate experience."
Translation: You're paying premium prices to ensure you don't have to mingle with the unwashed masses who saved up for a Carnival cruise.
Kluzner inadvertently revealed the class consciousness baked into the Oceania experience: "When you get on board, you're going to be traveling with like-minded travelers." This careful phrasing serves as code for "people in your socioeconomic bracket who share your values and won't make you uncomfortable with their difference."
The conversation reached its peak of unintentional parody when discussing Oceania's culinary offerings. "We have a ratio of one chef for every 10 guests," Kluzner boasted, a staffing ratio that would make most public schools and hospitals weep with envy.
Hansen couldn't help but salivate over his memory of "the Miso Glaze Seabass that is wrapped in a bamboo leaf. And when they uncork it, it just opens up. It's phenomenal." One wonders if he displayed the same enthusiasm when discussing Tucson's growing food insecurity issues or the fact that school lunch debt remains a reality for many American children.
But why worry about such mundane concerns when there's bamboo-wrapped sea bass to be had on the high seas?
The Paradox of Privilege: Reflection and Reality
As the final notes of this symphony to privileged globe-trotting faded, discerning listeners might have noticed what went conspicuously unmentioned throughout the hour: any discussion of sustainable tourism, the economic realities of the destinations described, or the environmental impact of these carbon-intensive travel methods.
There was not a word about Ireland's housing emergency or the economic struggles facing many Irish citizens, and there was not a whisper about the environmental impact of cruise ships, even the smaller ones, with their massive carbon footprints and waste management issues.
Instead, the show presented travel as a commodity to be consumed rather than an exchange to be negotiated ethically—experiences to be purchased rather than relationships to be built with understanding and respect for the places visited.
Yet travel, at its best, can be transformative rather than extractive. It can open minds, build cross-cultural understanding, and inspire a more connected approach to our shared global challenges. The question remains whether the ultra-luxe experiences marketed on shows like this contribute to that transformation or simply reinforce the bubbles of privilege that already insulate the affluent from the realities faced by most of the world's population.
The most exclusive souvenir might be the ability to return home with a deeper understanding of one's place in the world, rather than just another story about the thread count of Egyptian cotton sheets at a five-star resort.
A Better Way Forward
There's a more hopeful vision of travel that balances the joy of discovery with responsibility—one that respects host communities, treads lightly on fragile environments, and seeks genuine connection rather than curated experiences.
This alternative approach doesn't require sleeping in drafty hostels or abandoning all comfort (though it might mean occasionally standing in line with—gasp—regular people). It simply asks travelers to consider the full context of their journeys: Who benefits from your tourism dollars? How can your presence support rather than extract from local communities? What's the true cost of that perfect Instagram moment?
As we navigate a world in which the climate crisis and inequality continue to intensify, these questions become more than theoretical exercises—they become moral imperatives.
And that's where publications like Three Sonorans come in. We're committed to peeling back the glossy veneer of consumer culture to examine the structures beneath. Whether it's unpacking the politics of luxury travel or investigating local issues that affect our community's most vulnerable members, we're here to ask the hard questions that commercial media often skirts.
To continue this work, we need your support. Consider subscribing to our Substack to keep independent, progressive analysis coming to your inbox. Every subscription helps us maintain our independence and our ability to speak truth to power.
What's your experience with travel in our unequal world? Have you found ways to explore that feel both enriching and ethical? How do you balance the desire to see the world with the responsibility to protect it? Drop your thoughts in the comments below—we're building this consciousness-raising community together, one conversation at a time.
Because the most meaningful journey might be the one toward a more just and sustainable world—and that's a trip we all need to take together.
Quotes
"The air here is just incredible. It's so special. You're sitting 3,000 miles from the North American continent... so bottom line: air pollution, it just doesn't exist here." —Bill Buckmaster, seemingly unaware of the irony of flying thousands of miles to appreciate clean air
"When you have that kind of image in your mind for the rest of your life, Ryan Hansen, how do you put a price on that, sir?" —Bill Buckmaster, asking a rhetorical question about the value of travel experiences at luxury resorts that absolutely do put a price on such experiences
"With Oceania, you're only sailing with hundreds, not thousands. There's no lines. There's no waiting." —Scott Kluzner, Oceania Cruises, emphasizing exclusivity as the primary selling point
"We've worked tirelessly over the years to handpick who we work with. Basically, our guests get the benefit of accessing our little black book of only the best local specialists." —Emma Power, Brendan Vacations, describing how the company commodifies access to "authentic" Irish experiences
"We have a ratio of one chef for every 10 guests." —Scott Kluzner, Oceania Cruises, highlighting a staffing luxury that unintentionally highlights resource inequality in global tourism
People Mentioned with Quotes
Bill Buckmaster (Radio show host, calling in from Hawaii)
Ryan Hansen (President of Bon Voyage Travel, guest host): "I'm not lulled to sleep, but I'm getting very jealous with every phrase that you share, Bill Buckmaster, about your Hawaiian experience." —Responding to Buckmaster's descriptions of Hawaii
Emma Power (Brendan Vacations representative): "It's such a unique opportunity to experience an authentic Irish home" —Describing paid experiences in Irish homes that are marketed as "authentic"
Scott Kluzner (VP of Strategic Accounts, Oceania Cruises): "When you get on board, you're going to be traveling with like-minded individuals" —Using coded language that essentially means "people of your same socioeconomic class"
Barack Obama (Former US President): Not directly quoted, but mentioned by Buckmaster as having "switched beach houses" on Lanikai Beach, used as a celebrity endorsement of the location
Rory McElroy (Professional golfer): Not directly quoted, but mentioned as having a dedicated suite at Ashford Castle that Hansen had stayed in, demonstrating the property's connection to wealthy celebrities
Have a scoop or a story you want us to follow up on? Send us a message!
