💡 Prop 414: A Controversial Solution to Tucson's Safety Crisis

A critical examination of a sales tax measure that may not address the root problems facing our city; Chief Kasmar calls for accountability and community action.

Based on the Buckmaster show for 1/25/25 on KVOI-1030AM.

"Out of all those incidents, zero involved somebody who didn't have citizenship."

• Police Chief addressing immigration and crime, directly challenging xenophobic narratives about immigrant crime

---

🙊 Notable quotes from the show

Chief Chad Kasmar

• "It's almost two a day. So we certainly have a gun culture here in Tucson."

  • Context: Discussing 639 total firearm incidents in 2024

  • Significance: Revealing the pervasive gun violence in the city

• "The streets are not an easy place to live. A lot of those folks are armed with weapons to keep themselves safe."

  • Context: Discussing over a quarter of all homicides involving unsheltered population

  • Significance: Humanizing homeless individuals' survival strategies

• "Out of all those incidents, zero involved somebody who didn't have citizenship."

  • Context: Addressing immigration and crime

  • Significance: Directly challenging xenophobic narratives about immigrant crime

• "95% of my nearly 200 million dollar budget is personnel cost. That means I have 5% of the rest of my budget to run an entire department."

  • Context: Explaining financial constraints and Prop 414

  • Significance: Revealing systemic underfunding of public services

Dylan Smith

• "With only a handful of people around at this point... the money for it is going away."

  • Context: Discussing the closure of migrant shelters

  • Significance: Highlighting the precarious support for migrants

---

😽 Keepin’ It Simple Summary for Younger Readers
👧🏾✊🏾👦🏾

In a recent show, Tucson's Police Chief Chad Kasmar talked about the big problems our city faces with crime. 🚔 He shared some really serious numbers, like **64 people were killed** last year, and many of them were homeless. 💔 He said we need to change things—not just spend more money on police 💰, but find better ways to help everyone stay safe 🛡️ and support each other in the community. 🤝✨

---

---

🗝️ Takeaways

• 🚨 64 Homicides: Tucson experienced a 10% increase in homicides in 2024.

• 🤝 Vulnerable Population: More than a quarter of homicides involved homeless individuals.

• 💰 Financial Strain: 95% of the police budget goes to personnel costs, leaving little for resources.

• ❓ Questioning Solutions: Prop 414 raises concerns about the effective use of funds and its impacts on the community.

• 🛡️ Call for Responsibility: Police Chief Kasmar emphasizes the need for responsible gun ownership and community involvement.

---

Tucson's Reckoning: Chief Kasmar Unveils the City's Painful Realities

On a bone-chillingly cold Friday morning in January 2025, Tucson's Police Chief Chad Kasmar laid bare the raw, unvarnished truth of our city's struggles during the Buckmaster Show.

What emerged was more than a crime report—it was a profound diagnosis of urban survival in a system teetering on the edge of collapse.

🚨 The Numbers That Bleed: Tucson's 2024 Crime Landscape

Let's be crystal clear: 2024 was not just a tough year. It was a testament to the systemic failures that continue to plague our community.

The statistics are brutal:

• 64 homicides (a 10% increase)

• 175 non-fatal shootings

• 639 total firearm incidents

• Nearly a third of homicides involved the unsheltered population

"It's almost two [gun incidents] a day," Kasmar noted with a mix of professional detachment and underlying frustration. "We certainly have a gun culture here in Tucson."

The Unsheltered Crisis: Invisible Victims

Perhaps the most heart-wrenching revelation came from the chief's acknowledgment that 17 of 64 homicides, that’s more than a quarter of all homicides, involved homeless individuals. This isn't just a crime statistic—it's an indictment of our collective failure to protect our most vulnerable residents.

"The streets are not an easy place to live," Kasmar admitted, revealing a rare moment of human vulnerability. "A lot of those folks are armed with weapons to keep themselves safe."

💰 Prop 414: A Progressive's Dilemma

Enter Proposition 414—a sales tax measure that promises to solve everything and nothing simultaneously.

Kasmar's candid breakdown reveals the department's desperate financial straits:

• 95% of his nearly $200 million budget goes to personnel costs

• Only 5% remains for everything else: fleet, equipment, technology

"Cops cars now are $100,000 for a fully equipped cop car," he explained. "I've had Fords on order for two and a half years."

The Progressive Critique

While Kasmar presented the proposition as a comprehensive solution, we must interrogate its core assumptions:

• Does more policing actually solve root community problems?

• How does this tax disproportionately impact working-class Tucsonans?

• Are we investing in genuine community healing or merely expanding surveillance?

🌈 Beyond the Blue Line: Nuanced Perspectives

Kasmar surprisingly challenged some typical law enforcement narratives:

Immigration and Crime

"Out of all those incidents, zero involved someone who didn't have citizenship."

This direct refutation of xenophobic narratives is crucial. Tucson remains an "immigrant welcoming community"—a stance with real economic and moral consequences.

Gun Culture and Accountability

The chief didn't just blame criminals. He called for "responsible gun ownership":

• Securing weapons properly

• Addressing youth gun incidents

• Recognizing the complex social dynamics behind gun violence

The Humanitarian Data Point

One statistic cuts through the noise: a 90% crime solvency rate. But Kasmar was quick to contextualize this:

• National average is around 50%

• Requires community trust

• Depends on competent, dedicated detectives

"It means people are communicating when they're victims of crime," he noted—a subtle call for community solidarity.

Conclusion: Beyond the Numbers

Tucson stands at a crossroads. Prop 414 isn't just a tax measure—it's a referendum on how we view community safety, social support, and collective responsibility.

Call to Action

• Critically examine the proposition's underlying assumptions

• Demand transparent, equitable municipal spending

• Push for solutions that address root causes of community violence

• Support comprehensive social services

The desert doesn't just reflect our struggles—it demands our most compassionate, strategic response.

Stay critical. Stay human.

---

👥 People Mentioned:

• Bill Buckmaster

  • Role: Radio show host

  • Station: KVOI 1030

  • Memorable characteristic: 37-year veteran of Tucson radio and TV

• Chad Kasmar

  • Role: Tucson Police Chief

  • Key focuses:

    • Crime statistics

    • Public safety

    • Prop 414 analysis

  • Notable quote: "I'm not looking to fill jails, but I'm looking to hold people accountable who are breaking the law and are creating violence in our community."

• Dylan Smith

  • Role: Editor/Publisher of TucsonSentinel.com

  • Key contributions:

    • Providing context to police chief's statements

    • Discussing migrant shelter closures

    • Representing local independent journalism

---

---

---

☕ If you enjoyed this article, give us a tip! We 🤎☕‼️

---