๐๏ธ๐จ Pima County Libraries at a Crossroads: Digital Age Challenges
๐งโ๐คโ๐ง Staffing Woes: The Human Element in a Digital World ๐ป๐ฑ Digital Revolution: How E-books are Reshaping Libraries ๐๏ธ๐ Reimagining Spaces: The Evolving Role of Library Buildings
๐ฝ Keepinโ It Simple Summary for Younger Readers
๐ง๐พโ๐พ๐ฆ๐พ
๐๐๏ธ The Pima County libraries are changing! ๐ฑ๐ป More people are borrowing e-books instead of paper books. The libraries need more workers, even though they have money to hire them. ๐๏ธ๐ Some libraries might close, while others might change how they look and what they do. The library wants to hear what people think about these changes to make sure everyone can still use and enjoy the libraries in the future!
๐๏ธ Takeaways
๐ Over 50% of library checkouts are now digital
๐ผ 43 vacancies across 27 library locations despite a $56 million budget
๐ฆ $1 million allocated for security measures
๐ค Partnerships with health agencies and community centers being explored
๐ฃ๏ธ Community input is crucial for future library plans
๐๐ฎ Pima County Public Library: Navigating Challenges and Charting a Course for the Future
Pima County Public Library Director Amber Mathewson recently addressed the complex challenges and potential changes facing the library system. In a Sunday op-ed in the Arizona Daily Star and an interview on Monday's Bill Buckmaster Show, Mathewson outlined a vision for the future that balances tradition with innovation while addressing immediate operational hurdles.
This article explores the multifaceted issues presented by Mathewson, examining the library's current state, proposed changes, and the path forward.
๐๏ธ The Current Landscape
Pima County's library system demonstrates impressive engagement. Over 280,000 county residents hold library cards, and more than 160,000 of those cardholders have used their cards at least once in the past year. Thousands more without cards regularly visit the 27 library branches for various purposes, from attending community meetings to utilizing public spaces.
However, the digital revolution has significantly impacted library operations. Last year, digital checkouts surpassed physical checkouts for the first time, accounting for over 50% of all materials borrowed.
This shift has affected branch visits and is reshaping how the library allocates its resources. Mathewson noted that while this year's collection budget still slightly favors physical materials, she expects digital acquisitions to overtake physical ones in the coming year.
๐ฅ Staffing Challenges: A Paradox of Plenty
The Pima County Public Library system faces a perplexing staffing crisis that defies simple solutions. Despite a substantial operating budget of $56 million, which includes surplus funds, the library currently grapples with 43 vacancies across its 27 locations. This staffing shortage has created a domino effect, impacting employee morale, curtailing program offerings, and necessitating reduced hours of operation at some branches.
Mathewson highlighted that these staffing challenges persist despite increases in pay and benefits, pointing to a complex issue that money alone cannot solve. The difficulty in attracting and retaining qualified staff stems from various factors:
Competitive Job Market: With many sectors offering remote work and flexible schedules, traditional library positions face stiff competition.
Educational Requirements: Many library positions require advanced degrees, yet the compensation may not align with the investment in education, especially compared to other fields requiring similar qualifications.
Evolving Role of Librarians: Library work has changed significantly, increasingly involving social service aspects that some potential candidates may find challenging or unexpected.
Lengthy Hiring Process: Mathewson noted that while job fairs attract numerous applicants, extensive vetting often results in fewer successful hires.
Burnout and Turnover: Due to vacancies, existing staff face increased workloads, potentially leading to burnout and further turnover.
Public Sector Constraints: Despite having funds available, public sector hiring often involves more rigid processes and pay scales than the private sector, limiting flexibility in recruitment.
Changing Perceptions: The role of libraries in the digital age is evolving, and some potential candidates may not fully appreciate the dynamic and vital role modern librarians play in their communities.
The library has participated in county-wide job fairs and plans to attend more, but these efforts have yet to address the staffing shortfall fully. Mathewson expressed that while receiving many applications, converting these into successful hires remains challenging.
This staffing paradoxโhaving financial resources but lacking human resourcesโunderscores the need for innovative approaches to recruitment, retention, and possibly restructuring library services. As the library system evolves to meet changing community needs, solving this staffing puzzle remains a critical priority for ensuring its ability to fulfill its mission effectively.
๐ฐ Financial Considerations
While funding isn't the primary concernโthanks to consistent support from property taxes and the Board of Supervisorsโthe library faces rising costs in several areas. The price of physical books has approximately doubled in recent years, with a book that once cost $24 now typically priced around $48. Digital materials, especially e-books, can be even more expensive, with some digital copies costing up to $85.
Security has become another significant expense, with $1 million budgeted this year for security guards and off-duty officers. This increased need for security reflects broader societal challenges, as libraries often serve as de facto sanctuaries for unhoused individuals and those struggling with mental health issues.
๐ฎ Proposed Changes and Future Vision
Mathewson and her team have drafted proposals for the library's future in light of these challenges. While emphasizing that no decisions are final and community input is crucial, some of the key considerations include:
Potential Branch Consolidation: Initially, the proposal suggested closing three branches by the end of 2024. However, in response to community concerns, these proposed closures have been tabled for this year while more input is gathered.
Main Library Redesign: The downtown main library is being evaluated for potential downsizing or relocation, and discussions are underway about cost-effective alternatives that could still effectively serve the downtown area.
Community Outreach: Mathewson envisions a more dynamic role for library staff, with increased presence at community events, programs conducted at community centers, and efforts to bring materials directly to underserved populations.
Digital Services Expansion: Continued investment in digital resources is planned, focusing on balancing the availability of digital and physical materials to meet diverse community needs.
Partnerships and Collaborations: The library is exploring partnerships with health agencies to offer wellness services and collaborating with community centers to maintain service access.
๐ฃ๏ธ Community Engagement and Decision-Making
Mathewson emphasized the importance of community input in shaping the library's future. The administration actively seeks feedback through various channels, including the library's website and direct communication with the Library Advisory Board.
No immediate changes are planned for the current calendar year, allowing time for thorough community consultation. Ultimately, the Pima County Board of Supervisors will make final decisions, balancing community desires with fiscal responsibility.
๐งฉ Challenges and Considerations
As the library system evolves, it faces several key challenges:
Balancing traditional and modern roles
Addressing broader community needs
Infrastructure and space utilization
Digital rights management
๐
Future Outlook
Despite these challenges, Mathewson's vision for the future is one of expansion rather than contraction. The goal is to bring library services to more county residents through traditional branches, digital access, or innovative outreach programs.
Key aspects of this future vision include:
Adapting to changing usage patterns
Expanding community reach
Addressing aging infrastructure
Enhancing partnerships with community organizations
The Pima County Public Library system stands at a critical juncture, facing challenges that reflect broader technological shifts, community needs, and resource allocation. As the library moves forward, the emphasis on community engagement, fiscal responsibility, and innovative service delivery will be crucial in shaping a system that continues to serve as a vital resource for all Pima County residents.
The Pima County Public Library's journey through these challenges exemplifies the broader evolution of public libraries nationwide. As these institutions adapt to the digital age and expand their roles as community centers, the experiences and decisions made in Pima County may offer valuable insights for library systems grappling with similar issues across the country.